I have to agree on the Necters, not my bag.
I rather liked the Vanilla/Cinnamon when I went on the tour so I bought a bottle. I had another taste of it at the MeadFest and still liked the taste. I am planning on cracking the bottle I bought at Xmas time to give it a more thourough inspection.
Also from the tasting/tour:
Traditional Mountain Honey Wine: This is the first Redstone I had. I bought a bottle a couple of years ago. Up to that point I had only had Chaucers (which I don't care for at all) so I thought I had hit the gold mine. I am much more 'experienced' now. It's not bad mead, but for my personal tastes it's not great mead either.
Boyesnberry & Plum: I rather liked these two, especially the plum. Again, I had no melomel's prior to tasting these. After some of the ones I tried at the MeadFest I would consider them middle of the road. Probably worth the money if you like either of those flavors.
The others I can honestly say that I tried but don't remeber any longer.
Reserve: This is the candy baby! I got a sample at the tour/tasting ($3.00 for about an ounce or two) and spent about 15 minutes just breathing the vapors! Worth every penny. If I could manage this (and I will someday as Joe pointed out earler) I would be done. I would figure out a way to retire and spend my day drinking it, cooking with it, bathing in it, errr. Alright, lets just say I think it is good.
I would give Redstone 3-4 stars out of 5 in an overall review of their products. I think the thing that is really tough for them (and for Rabbit's Foot, or any of the other meaderies out there) is that they are in an akward position of being 'first'. They have the awesome burden of 1) getting people to try mead, 2) getting people to 'like' mead, 3) keep people wanting mead, and 4) turning a profit. Any one of those is a tall order.
These companies are pioneers of a sort and while I am sure David Myers, Julia Herz, Mike Faul, and all of the other meadery owners would love to crank out gallons and gallons of their respective 'reserves' they all have a bottom line that needs to get met. To move product they have to be able to cater to the public's taste which is a varied as the wind. For some people that will be Redstone's Traditional, for others it will be RabbitFoots's Cyser.
The point is, while it is good get get an opinion there is no substitute for tasting it yourself and making your own decision. I would highly suggest taking the tour/tasting.
And now that I have rambled on for an eternity...what was the question again?
-jb